Celebrate the festive season with our delectable pies! Now available for preorder are classic favorites like apple, pumpkin, and other fruit fillings, as well as indulgent choices like coconut cream and peanut butter (available in gluten-free options too).

Stahrs Cakes will be closed from July 11th to July 26th. We look forward to serving you with our delicious baked treats on July 27th.

Baked-to-Order Daily

Just For You

Experience the flavors of the season with our monthly menu - a tantalizing selection of delectable treats that are freshly crafted each month!

Customer Favorites

Cupcakes

$4.50 each

$26 /half dozen

$48 /dozen

Cookies

$3.00 each

$16 /half dozen

$30 /dozen

Cakes

$50: 6-inch

$65: 8-inch

$90: 10-inch

Brownies

$3.00 each

$16 /half dozen

$30 /dozen

Cinn-a-rolls

Bundt Cakes

Whoopie Pies

Pre-Order Menu

Pre-Order Your Sweet Delights! Choose from an array of mouthwatering flavors.

Cake Flavors

Chocolate
Mocha
German Chocolate
Cannoli
Gingerbread
Vanilla bean
Vanilla latte
Cookies ‘n cream
Salted caramel
Angel food
Graham cracker
Peanut butter
Mint chocolate
Peppermint Spice
Carrot
Red velvet (or any other color)
Coconut
Funfetti
Pumpkin
White chocolate
Pineapple
Cherry
Orange
Lemon
Strawberry
Raspberry
Banana
Passionfruit
Chantilly

Icings (Buttercreams)

Chocolate
Vanilla bean
Mocha
Peanut butter
MapleCream cheese
White chocolate
Latte
Caramel
Banana
Orange
Lemon
Strawberry
Cherry
Blueberry
Cookies ‘n cream
Passionfruit
Mint chocolate
Peppermint
Chantilly icing

Fillings

All fruits and jams
Chocolate mousse
Bavarian cream
Puddings
Ganache
Nutella

Getting your hands on these treats is as easy as pie – simply reach out to us and place your pre-order. Our team will ensure your chosen treats are prepared with utmost care, ready to be savored at your convenience.

December Flavors

German chocolate cupcakes with pecan coconut icing and chocolate buttercream

From $4.50

Dive into the rich symphony of flavors with our German Chocolate Cupcakes. Topped with luscious pecan coconut icing and chocolate buttercream, these cupcakes are a decadent delight for your taste buds.

Coconut Cake 6”

From $50

Experience the delicate essence of coconut in every bite with our 6” Coconut Cake. Finished with velvety coconut cream cheese buttercream, this cake is an elegant treat that's perfect for any occasion.

Red velvet topped with cream cheese buttercream

From $4.50

Indulge in the timeless allure of our Red Velvet Cupcakes. Topped with smooth cream cheese buttercream, these cupcakes are a perfect balance of rich cocoa and vibrant red velvet goodness.

Pumpkin Whoopie Pies Filled with Vanilla Bean Buttercream

From $4.00

Embrace the warmth of the season with our Pumpkin Whoopie Pies. Filled with luscious vanilla bean buttercream, these pies offer a delightful blend of spiced pumpkin goodness.

Grinch Cookies (Green Tinted Vanilla Cake Cookies)

From $3

Add a touch of whimsy to your festivities with our Grinch Cookies. These green-tinted vanilla cake cookies are not only delightful to look at but also a treat for your taste buds.

Muffins: paleo chocolate chocolate chip

From $3.75

Indulge guilt-free in the rich, grain-free decadence of our Paleo Chocolate Chocolate Chip Muffin. A blissful treat for your taste buds without compromising on your health-conscious choices.

Flavors

Cakes

6-inch $50 ⎮ 8-inch $65 ⎮ 10-inch $90 ⎮ Bundt Cakes $60

All cakes are starting prices. The price includes 4 layers of cake with 3 layers of filling and covered with fresh buttercream.

Other sizes and customization options available (call or e-mail for details).

German chocolate cake 6” $50

Rich chocolate cake filled with coconut pecan icing and covered with chocolate buttercream.

Coconut cake 6” $50

Light coconut cake with coconut cream cheese buttercream

Pumpkin Bundt cake 9” $60

Pumpkin cake filled with cinnamon streusel and topped with dark chocolate ganache

Chocolate Bundt cake 9” $60

Chocolate Bundt cake with dark chocolate ganache and peppermint pieces

Shoo Fly Cake 1/4 sheet $55

Moist molasses cake topped with a crumb topping

Cupcakes

$48/dozen ⎮ $26/half dozen ⎮ $4.50 each

Gluten free, vegan, and paleo options now available while supplies last or by pre-order!

Chocolate with chocolate or mocha buttercream

Vanilla bean with vanilla bean or chocolate buttercream

Apple with maple buttercream

Peanut butter chip with peanut butter buttercream

Salted caramel with salted caramel buttercream

Cupcakes

$48/dozen ⎮ $26/half dozen ⎮ $4.50 each

Gluten free, vegan, and paleo options now available while supplies last or by pre-order!

Chocolate cupcakes topped with chocolate or vanilla bean buttercream

Vanilla bean cupcakes topped with vanilla bean or chocolate buttercream

Red velvet topped with cream cheese buttercream

Gingerbread cupcakes topped with vanilla bean buttercream

Coconut cupcakes topped with coconut cream cheese buttercream

German chocolate cupcakes with pecan coconut icing and chocolate buttercream

Cookies, Whoopie Pies, and other Extras

$30/dozen ⎮ $16/half dozen ⎮
$3.00 each cookie ⎮
$4.00 each whoopie pies, brookie & bars

Cinn-a-rolls and Cookies n’ Cream Rolls available on Saturdays and available for pre-order anytime!

Cookies -$3 each

Chocolate chip

Soft sugar

Melted snowmen (chocolate cake cookies with icing)

Grinch cookies (green tinted vanilla cake cookies)

Decorated cookies $4 each

Gingerbread men

Variety of Christmas shaped sugar cookies(All decorated for Christmas)

Pumpkin whoopie pies filled with vanilla bean buttercream

Chocolate peppermint whoopie pies filled with vanilla bean buttercream and rolled in peppermint pieces

Breads (loaves are $5, muffins are $3.75)

Banana nut

Pumpkin chip

Muffins only: paleo chocolate chocolate chip

Bars $4 each

Brownies (fudgy chocolate brownie)

Pecan pie bars (shortbread crust topped with pecan pie topping)

Peppermint bark sold by 1 pound box ($15/box)

Dark chocolate with peppermint white chocolate and peppermint pieces

Pudding Pies

$25 each

Gluten free, vegan, and paleo options now available while supplies last or by pre-order!

Peanut Butter Pie

Gluten Free Banana Cream Pie

Special Diet

Vegan, Gluten-Free & Paleo Options!

Paleo chocolate cupcakes with chocolate fudge icing

From $5.00

Experience pure delight with our Paleo Chocolate Cupcakes, topped with velvety chocolate icing. Grain-free, sugar-free, and dairy-free, these cupcakes redefine sweetness without compromising on your dietary preferences.

Gluten free chocolate cupcakes with chocolate buttercream

From $5.00

Savor the classic goodness of chocolate in our Gluten-Free Chocolate Cupcakes. Perfectly moist and irresistibly chocolaty, these cupcakes cater to your sweet tooth while being gluten-free.

Vegan and gluten free red velvet with “cream cheese” icing

From $5.00

Enjoy the luxurious taste of our Vegan and Gluten-Free Red Velvet Cupcakes, adorned with velvety cream cheese icing. Free of animal products and gluten, these cupcakes are a delectable choice for all preferences.

Paleo espresso chip cookies

From $3

Wake up your senses with the bold flavor of our Paleo Espresso Chip Cookies. Crafted with care, these cookies offer a delightful blend of espresso and chocolate in every bite.

Muffins: paleo chocolate chocolate chip

From $3.75

Indulge guilt-free in the rich, grain-free decadence of our Paleo Chocolate Chocolate Chip Muffin. A blissful treat for your taste buds without compromising on your health-conscious choices.